Here are my answers to my Pretty Little Liars Theories Tag. Feel free to answer the questions using the #PLLTheoriesTag
1. Is Ali telling the truth? I’d like to think that she is, but sometimes I do doubt her intentions. It seems unlikely to me that with all these people helping her (Shana, Noel, Cece), that she wouldn’t able to work out who -A is. And more than that, I still don’t understand what was so bad that she couldn’t tell the police what had happened. They would have been able to help her locate who was threatening her. It seems more safe than hiding out on your own. Also some of the things and the timeline of events she has said don’t make sense. The Whole Spencer thing makes no sense but I did a post on that after the finale. I think for the most part that she is innocent but I also wouldn’t be surprised if they twisted it so that she was -A
2.Is Ezra trustworthy? Like I said with Alison, I would like to thing so and at the minute, I am 90% sure that he is trustworthy. The whole book thing turned out to be a bit boring to be honest but I think a great twist would be that Aria is A and Ezra is protecting her. However since this is very unlikely to happen, I’m gonna say that yes, he is trustworthy.
3. Who tried to kill Alison? I think it’ll be boring and be someone like Jason who was a suspect back in like Season 2. However I think it would be better if it was someone else, someone with a better motive, but then why would Mrs D protect them. Since Mr DiLaurentis is coming back, maybe he tried to kill Alison? He may play a bigger role than we first thought? I don’t know.
4. Who killed Mrs D? This is tricky one. I think it is Peter Hastings because I think whatever Melissa told him had to do with Mrs DiLaurentis and it was important that the information didn’t get out, so he killed her.
5. What does Melissa know? Like I said briefly in Q4, I think Melissa knows something about Mrs D. Maybe Melissa, Cece and Mrs D saw Spencer kill Sara Harvey and Mrs Dilaurentis was planning on telling the police but Peter put a stop to it. We know that Cece and Mrs D apparently saw Spencer hit someone so maybe Melissa did aswell. We did see her having a conversation with Cece that night. Maybe she didn’t see but Cece told her afterwords… I’m not sure.
6. Did Cece kill Wilden? Yes I think she did. I think he knew Ali was alive and was blackmailing Cece for her whereabouts.
7. Is Jason innocent? Hmm I’m not sure. He was quite sketchy in 4x23 so I think he is definitely hiding something. Where was he for all that time he was supposedly at the closed down rehab centre? Helping Alison maybe?
8. Who is in Ali’s grave? Although it would be a bit boring, I think it will be Sara Harvey. A lot of people say it could be Marion Cavanaugh but surely the autopsy would say 30-40 year old women(however old she was) rather than 16 year old girl. Or it could be the twin, whoever that may be. I’ve said many times that I think that Cece has a twin but check out my page for more posts on that.
9. Who was threatening Alison the day she disappeared? Was it Mona? I don’t think that it could have been Mona. I know Marlene has always said that Mona was Ali’s -A, but she ‘saved’ Ali. Surely if she had wanted her dead she would just hit her again. I think that the -A who was threatening Ali that night was the same -A that has started to threaten the girls now. I’d like that to be Wren but I just don’t know anymore
10. Is Maya still alive? I hope so. I loved Emaya but then I love Emison as well. I don’t think that Maya’s storyline was ever wrapped up properly so I would love to see a possible conclusion to that whether it be she is alive or just a conclusion on her death. I know they said the Nate was the killer but I don’t think it was- he never said it outright. Also, I’m still pretty convinced that in 3x24, it was Maya who Toby saw in the woods. We never did find out about that.
11.Who is Beach Hottie? There’s not many guys left in Rosewood that we know Ali hasn’t had a relationship with. Are Boardshorts and Beach Hottie two different people? I think they probably are so I think that Beach Hottie is Wren because I really can’t think of anyone else Ali hasn’t already been revealed to have a relationship with
12. Who is -A? Wren. I’d love -A to be Aria but it will probably be Wren. I don’t think that Wren is big,powerful A though. That will probably be a twin but I think that Wren will be the next person to be revealed.
Thought I’d make this because I did one about this time last year. Feel free to do this Tag with the # ‘PLLTheoriesTag’ so I can read them all. I’m going to complete it in a different post.
1. Is Ali telling the truth?
2.Is Ezra trustworthy?
3. Who tried to kill Alison?
4. Who killed Mrs D?
5. What does Melissa know?
6. Did Cece kill Wilden?
7. Is Jason innocent?
8. Who is in Ali’s grave?
9. Who was threatening Alison the day she disappeared? Was it Mona?
10. Is Maya still alive?
11.Who is Boardshorts?
12. Who is -A?
So yeah, check out my post with my answers which will be posted shortly after this one.
I’m thinking that maybe Alison doesn’t know the full story… Cause she was like buried in the ground and then she went of to the hospital so it’s not like she saw everything that happened? And then we never saw the whole scene of when Spencer hit someone because in the promo, she had mud and blood on her face.
I definitely think that there is more to this Spencer story than they have revealed as of yet.
There is a huge probability that the guy in the hoodie has to be the one of guys we’ve seen in 4x24; if there would be anyone who wasn’t seen in the episode it would be obvious that’s him!
So, suspects are:
Garrett(I crossed him because he’s dead?)
I think we can throw Peter and Holbrook out of the list because they were in the town while they were looking for the girls. There’s left:
I put my money on Jason or Ian.
Ian is dead aswell
Maybe I’m just he only one but this episode left me really confused with Spencer. If she went back to sleep after seeing Alison, then when did she say ‘she’s gone, I’ve looked everywhere for her’…
Spencer must have woken up again, gone to look for Ali (drugs+alcohol=memory loss) and then gone back and said it. So therefore, it is possible that she was the one that killed Sara or whoever is in Ali’s grave.
If anyone would like to explain to me if I’m just stupid or send me their own theories on this, my ask is always open :)
I cant imagine that they are going to make this that easy. I really feel like we are missing something. Right now Jason and Wren seem like the most likely candidates. And I think we can all agree the more obvious it is, the less likely we are right.
So thinking outside the box, I have come up…
Defiantly agree with number 2, I was thinkin that during t episode
I bet after the liars yell at A to take off the mask A will panic and jump off that roof they’re standing on and BAM! dark screen no reveal till season 5 or more likely till season 25.
Tell me you see it too!!!!!
Spencer’s twin! I’m calling it….
n the ending scene we see A fixing one of the dresses the girls wear next episode. I looked at one of the pictures and the dress as i suspected, was Spencers. The song caught my attention
'Hey Little Sister' it kept repeating and it made me automatically think of Mellissa. However it could also be Jason as he is spencers half brother and potentially Alison. Si are they A?
Just a thought